Great pizza! Staff is awesome.... Highly recommended!

Really enjoyed our dinner here, the wings were excellent as was the pizza. One thing that was kind of annoying was I didn't seem to notice a menu with prices and the board up top did not have any prices. Luckily there were some family meal specials with prices listed and we went with the wings and the half sheet with a 2 liter for about $35.

Amazing service. The employees alone are reason to go. Only issue I had was that I wanted two different sauces on my wings, like 6 of each flavor and they combined sauces. It turned out ok, but in the future I'll order 2 6 pieces instead of a 12 piece. The wings were cooked really well though. Pasta was great, stromboli was awesome. Really not a single complaint other than the wing miscommunication. Highly recommend if you're in the area.

Haven't went there in a few years ordered a personal pizza for my mom was good she sed....... but service was not so good ask a question about pizza in the already made case n the young lady was like not very customer friendly in my opinion probably won't be back

Called in an order as I have done so many many of times here @BlueStone Pizza and this time I ordered just a sheet pizza extra cheese and a chicken spiedie salad. Unfortunately, I didn't tell my spouse I ordered my salad oops he didn't know you ask for it, entirely my fault but anyway, I called right up seeing I was working and they refunded the salad no issue at all. I highly recommend and their sweet and salty chicken pizza is to die for, especially if you love the combo (S&S) as much as I do!

Their pizza is the best around for sure. Great prices always easy to work with truthfully haven’t messed up a pizza yet.

Fast, friendly and kinda funky! Try their daily specials - these guys are really working towards creating a unique pizza/wings/etc experience for their guests. The decor is like a Bass Pro shops sort of which was really homey touch. We had the large cheese pizza and it fed our family of four, made in minutes from scratch.

Ordered the day before for take out the next day. Order was ready! Didn't have to wait at all. Pizza of course was wonderful. Was for an Eagle Scout Project. 2sheet pizzas. One with pepperoni, the other with pepperoni, onions, n green peppers.

Good tasting pizza and wings when they get it right. Have ordered take out a number of times recently and there have been issues. Most recently they burned the pizza and hardly sauced the wings. To be fair we called back and the manager replaced everything so I know they care about making the customer happy. Staff are always friendly. Good value deals on sheets and wings if you have an appetite!!

Everything about Bluestone is great EXCEPT when you walk in there and it's so disgustingly hot. The poor employees working in the heat has to be complete hell for them. I cannot imagine how hot it gets for the kids in the back. The poor kids have been kids have been dealing with this for awhile now. Hopefully it changes soon for them!

Pizza was good. Everyone is so friendly. ... it had to be 100 degrees in there.. I don't know how the workers can work in that. And why can't the owner get fans....or close... you have good employees to work in this heat with no fans ir air..

Great pizza !! I would recommend to a friend!

I highly recommend this restaurant! The sheet pizza party pack is my favorite thing to purchase here. It is the sheet pizza, 36 wings and 2 2 liter bottles of soda! The pizza and wings are superb! I gave 4 stars because once in a whole the pizza gets over cooked and the garlic knots I was not impressed with and the one time I got them they tasted freezer burned but they were ordered a few years ago.

I ordered an 18’ round and mild garlic wings. When I arrived the server was prompt to ask my name and grabbed my order. The atmosphere was laid back. The workers were all smiling and yes, even a kid was dancing while food prepping. I’d rather see that than grumpy people not getting my order right! Wouldn’t you?! The supreme pizza I ordered is absolutely one of the best I’ve ever had. Keep up the good work Blue Stone 👏🏼 thank you!

Easy on phone order. Great mild hot wings. Tasty garlic bread. But was not too happy with your reviewers stating great pizza Mine was not all that great. Price for all was little high for a small town. Just a Sunday afternoon movie and snack time.

We wanted subs on our way back to PA from NY and this was a choice closest to the rest stop. The subs were delicious, the fries were a nice portion, the sauce the was ordered was very good. When going back to give Cheryl our thoughts on the food she was very kind. She offered extra for the minor and accepted mistakes to the subs, she also suggested another sauce that one of our party has said he would make the drive from Ephrata pa to get. Thank you Cheryl for your kindness and for advertising on Google so we were able to find a new stopping place for this trip.

We stopped on our way to NJ and found this place. Got veggie pan pizza. Greatly made pizza. Good that we skipped the other fast food guys.

Above average on everything we ordered, service was above average and look of the place is a little deceiving. We were not sure if they were open or not but we are sure glad we checked. Everything went how it should have, therefore 5 stars. We had mozzarella sticks (great) Philly cheese steaks (great and the roll was toasted up nice. Lettuce was fresh and meat was great.) Mild wings - normal size and sauce but that's great that being "average" was the lowest point of our visit. We would return if we lived closer. Maybe we will make it pur half way stop on our way to going snow mobiling.

I wouldnt say it's the best pizza, but it's really not bad. My mozz sticks sadly were definitely made way before the pizza. Had to wait for the pizza but my fiance's wings and my mozz sticks were loop warm. The cheesy garlic bread was alright. If you like alot of butter or oil ( idk what they use) then youd like it but they were so greasy it actually made me nauseated. Again, not bad, but not somewhere I'd go if if somewhere else was open

I've lived in Hallstead for over 2 years. Haven't been because no prices. I won't order food if you can't show me what it costs. Yes I read your explanation on another review, that was a poor excuse. Would you commit to purchasing a car if you had no idea what it cost? Im not the only one that complains about the lack of prices.

Stopped while driving home from Philadelphia. Looked a little ruff but when you have a two year screaming pizza for an hour, you do what you got to do! The staff was excellent. That is always very important too me. The pizza was good!!! I did not have high expectations so was pleasantly surprised. The pizza shop really needs a renovation however the whole plaza it is in does. Could stand a good cleaning. Any place that can deal with my family of 5 and 90 different requests plus have good food, deserves special recognition.

First time going to this place today and let me tell you the food is awesome, amazing and delicious! The inside was very clean and inviting. The staff was polite and friendly. I would highly recommend this pizzeria! 10/10😋 My tummy is smiling! Thank you!

First time ever ordering from here and everything was very good. We ordered a turkey sub, cheese steak, Hotwing Pizza,Greek salad, Garlic Parm fries, and pickle chips. The only thing is the pizza could have been a little saucier and cooked longer. Other than that minor thing everything was great. Great prices, Great portions, and very polite staff. We will return.

I can’t say enough good things about the staff here. Not only was the pizza absolutely delicious, but the team went above and beyond to make the experience unforgettable. From the moment I walked in, I felt like more than just a customer — I felt like a guest. One staff member noticed I was having trouble deciding and took the time to explain their favorites, even offering a sample of their house sauce (which was amazing, by the way). Another went out of their way to check on our table multiple times, making sure everything was just right — without being overbearing. It’s rare these days to find service that feels this personal and genuine. The passion and care the staff put into their work really shines through. It’s the kind of place where you leave feeling full, happy, and already planning your next visit. Highly recommend — not just for the food, but for the people who make it such a great place!

Absolutely delicious! And the environment is a place I would enjoy eating at. My friend is Italian and even he says that their pizza is really good!

We happened upon this little slice of awesomeness on a short vacation/family trip. Cheryl, the cashier, was just the friendliest, most helpful lady! She(actually) took the time to check the ingredient list on a few items for us....(we have a couple of us with severe food allergies!) Without hesitation,or attitude,just a friendly smile! Definetly recommend this place!

2nd time eating here and the sausage and pepper calzones are delicious. The staff are great. Gonna make it a habit to eat here when we're in the area.